Immigration

3 min read

NRW corrects deportation charter account: 35 people, not one, on board

North Rhine-Westphalia's refugee ministry says its initial account of a September 29 deportation charter omitted 34 people being sent to Albania. The Boeing 737 carried one Lebanese national to Sofia before continuing to Albania with the other deportees.

lake-av1wquo49a1aoxfadqulihev-716f6132-b8a3-434e-92ae-f49a6e704ff3-0.webp

AI summary

  • A ministry spokeswoman told Bild that the initial account of the September 29 flight had given a misleading impression.
  • Another 34 people on the same aircraft were being deported to Albania after the stop in Sofia.
  • Media reports estimated the cost of the September 29, 2026 charter to Sofia at about 60,000 euros.
  • The state government's response to a parliamentary question put the 2025 total for seven NRW charter flights at 515,936.38 euros.
  • The ministry attributes low passenger numbers to destination country quotas and last-minute cancellations, which it says cannot be controlled.

Albania leg omitted from initial account

The correction follows a Kölner Stadt-Anzeiger report that a chartered passenger plane from Düsseldorf to Sofia carried just one person required to leave Germany. The ministry initially confirmed that account amid a dispute over deportation costs.

A ministry spokeswoman told Bild that questions about the reported single-passenger operation prompted a review. The ministry, led by Green politician Verena Schäffer, acknowledged that its first response about the September 29 flight was incomplete and had given a misleading impression.

Only one deportee was bound for the Bulgarian capital, the spokeswoman explained, but another 34 people on the same aircraft were being deported to Albania. The ministry's original account had left out the onward leg after the stop in Sofia.

Costs and charter totals

Media reports estimated the cost of the September 29, 2026, charter to Sofia at about 60,000 euros. According to the Kölner Stadt-Anzeiger and Bild, the ministry in Düsseldorf had not yet received the final bill.

Separate figures in the state government's response to a parliamentary question, Landtag document 18/21860, put the total cost of seven NRW charter deportation flights in 2025 at 515,936.38 euros. The average was about 73,705 euros, with individual flights costing roughly 49,750 to 98,219 euros. Five flew from Düsseldorf to Sofia and two to Zagreb.

The ministry told the Kölner Stadt-Anzeiger that the state booked 17 charter aircraft across 2025 and 2026, transporting 143 people to other EU countries under the Dublin system.

At the federal level, Merkur reported that the most expensive charter deportation flight in the first half of 2026 was a Leipzig-to-Pakistan flight costing about 518,000 euros.

Passenger limits and late cancellations

The ministry attributes low passenger numbers on charter operations to limits set by destination countries, which it says often accept no more than ten people per operation. NRW says it cannot influence those quotas because negotiations are handled at the federal level.

The ministry also cited last-minute obstacles: people scheduled for deportation may not be found, may become medically unfit to travel or may already have left voluntarily. It said charters generally must be canceled at least 72 hours before departure to avoid charges. If most passengers drop out on departure day, a free cancellation is no longer possible.

NRW's first self-organized deportation charter, about a year and a half before the September 2026 case, took four Syrian men and three Afghan men to Sofia. The state rented an entire Airbus, carrying only the deportees, escorts and crew.

According to Merkur, about 56,000 people in North Rhine-Westphalia are required to leave Germany. About 11,000 are subject to enforceable removal without a Duldung, or tolerated status.

FDP seeks answers

The Free Democratic Party (FDP) in North Rhine-Westphalia has submitted a formal parliamentary inquiry about the deportation flights. State lawmaker Alexander Steffen blamed Schäffer for the episode, telling Bild that her party was neither capable of organizing deportations nor willing to do so.

The state government still has four weeks to respond to the inquiry.

#Refugees & Asylum#North Rhine-Westphalia#Immigration
← Back to Immigration

Related news