Which contracts the ruling covers
The decision concerned the special termination right in Section 230(5) of the Telecommunications Act (TKG), not the abolition of the billing arrangement known as the Nebenkostenprivileg itself.
For supply agreements signed before December 1, 2021, the provision allows either party to terminate without a notice period, effective from July 1, 2024, unless the parties agreed to different terms. It also bars the other party from claiming damages for that termination.
The court's First Senate dismissed complaints brought by Hamburg-based regional operator Willytel and two Bavarian companies, Rehnig Breitbandnetze & Kabelfernsehen GmbH and Ziegelmeier GmbH. Their cases were registered as 1 BvR 1803/22, 1 BvR 2058/22 and 1 BvR 2234/22.
How the change affected tenants
Most landlords ended their collective TV agreements as of July 2024, according to dpa reporting published by Volksstimme. Tenants wishing to continue receiving television then needed their own contracts or could join new collective agreements. Those new arrangements are paid separately from rent, and participation is voluntary. The previous collective contracts typically lasted 10 to 20 years.
The court traced the Nebenkostenprivileg, a provision in Germany's operating-cost regulation, to the 1970s. It was designed to limit the proliferation of satellite dishes on apartment-building roofs and encourage cable network expansion. More than 12 million tenancies were affected.
Germany's Monopolkommission had long sought its abolition, arguing that the arrangement left tenants without sufficient transparency or choice and distorted competition. According to the Federal Ministry for Digital and Transport, the legislature's 2021 decision to end it implemented EU legal requirements and strengthened competition among TV and internet-access providers.
Why the court allowed the burden on operators
The court found the restriction on operators' property rights proportionate and permissible as a law defining the content and limits of those rights. It also rejected the challenges based on occupational freedom under Article 12(1) of the Basic Law, general freedom of action under Article 2(1), and the prohibition on retroactive legislation.
A central issue was how much time operators had to adjust. Counting from the Bundestag's April 22, 2021, resolution, the transition period through June 30, 2024, guaranteed their contracts a minimum remaining term of more than three years, regardless of individual circumstances. The court found that period sufficient and still within the legislature's discretion.
Presenting the judgment in Karlsruhe, court president Stephan Harbarth acknowledged that the operators faced a considerable overall burden. He said lawmakers had not exceeded their constitutional discretion, while emphasizing that the interference with the companies' property rights came close to the limits of what the constitution permits.
Government response and changing viewing habits
The federal government welcomed the judgment. Digital Minister Karsten Wildberger said it settled the legal uncertainty and benefited millions of tenants by securing their choice of TV reception and removing unwanted compulsory charges from rental expenses. He also argued that competition would determine the best offers and help drive modern fiber-optic expansion.
The mix of TV reception technologies has also changed. An AGF Videoforschung industry analysis cited in reporting on the ruling found that satellite dishes were the most common method at the start of 2026, serving around 43 percent of Germany's 41 million households. Cable's share had fallen to 36 percent, down from just under 44 percent in 2023, when it was still the leading technology. Internet-based TV doubled its share within two years to 19 percent.



