A disputed interpretation of the injuries
Freeman presented his conclusions at the Middle Temple, a historic London legal society, on Monday, November 16, 2026, according to The New York Times. He told the BBC that he spent a year examining the autopsy report and concluded that Epstein was likely strangled.
Epstein was found hanging in his New York jail cell on August 10, 2019, while awaiting trial. He was on suicide watch at the time.
The medical examiner's office said it continues to stand by its determination of suicide by hanging. The 2019 autopsy report described Epstein's injuries as consistent with suicide and found no defensive injuries of the kind expected in a homicide. Dr. Barbara Samson, who led the autopsy, told the BBC she fully supported the office's findings on the cause and manner of death.
Freeman disputes whether the injuries fit a hanging in the position described. He and his co-authors argue that the neck marks are best explained by strangulation from behind, most likely with a narrow, knotted fabric ligature. They also identify what they consider fingernail marks above the ligature mark, which Freeman says could reflect an attempt to pull the ligature away from the neck.
He also told the BBC that bleeding at Epstein's left shoulder and injuries to his face suggested an assault, attributing the facial injuries to blows. Freeman said he could not explain the full range of injuries as self-inflicted unless Epstein had intended to make a suicide look like a murder.
What Freeman reviewed
Freeman did not examine Epstein's body. His assessment rests on investigative records and photographs supplied by Epstein's brother, Mark, who has repeatedly promoted speculation about a possible murder plot.
According to CBS News, Freeman is editor-in-chief of the Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine. His collaborators were Anders Eriksson, a forensic medicine professor at Sweden's Umeå University, and Itiel Dror, whose research focuses on bias in forensic decision-making. All three presented their findings in London.
To reconstruct the scene, Freeman used corrections officer Michael Thomas' account of finding Epstein hanging from a bedpost, CBS News reported. Thomas agreed to an interview with investigators only after he was charged with crimes two years later.
Freeman also identified a narrow fabric ligature, formed into a loop with a double knot, that was found in a corner near the cell's desk. He says it fits the injuries and was not collected for the medical examiner, according to CBS News.
CBS News reported that an academic journal declined to publish Freeman's report. Freeman said its reviewers considered a peer-reviewed publication an inappropriate venue for criticism of a medical examiner's findings. He plans to resubmit the report.
Other forensic assessments
This is the second outside forensic report to challenge the suicide ruling, according to CBS News. In 2020, Mark Epstein hired forensic pathologist Dr. Michael Baden to examine the death. Baden also questioned the official conclusion, citing injuries to Epstein's neck.
Other specialists have been less definitive. The New York Times reported on November 16 that forensic pathologists who had reviewed some, but not all, of the autopsy photographs considered the neck mark unusual for a hanging. Some nevertheless said the images could be consistent with suicide and warned that the injuries alone did not establish what happened.
A separate Times investigation published in June 2026 examined tens of thousands of pages of newly released documents and Epstein's handwritten jail notes, according to CBS News. It found indications that he intended to take his own life. Almost none of the forensic experts interviewed for that investigation believed medical evidence alone could conclusively distinguish suicide from homicide.
The criminal case and longstanding speculation
Epstein was convicted in 2008 of soliciting prostitution from a minor. An agreement with prosecutors spared him a lengthy prison sentence. Eleven years later, he faced charges that he had operated a network of underage girls for sexual exploitation. He died before the case went to trial.
His connections to powerful people have accompanied years of conspiracy claims that he was killed in jail to silence him. Freeman told the BBC that, even if his conclusion is correct, he does not know who might have killed Epstein. He said he had formed no opinion on that question and had not investigated it.







